Chilling Video of Nancy Guthrie’s Bedroom Shows ‘Exactly’ How Her Abductor May Have ‘Walked Into’ Her Home: ‘If You Were a Bad Guy…’
It’s been over a month since Nancy Guthrie, Savannah Guthrie’s mom, was kidnapped. And though there are no clear leads and police have not yet identified a suspect, there’s a lot of looking back at what could have happened. Theories have sprung up. Every public appearance by Nancy is being scrutinized. What happened and how did it happen?
Former Fox News anchor Megyn Kelly unearthed a 2013 Today show segment featuring a look at Nancy Guthrie’s bedtime routine. In the video, Guthrie is in her bedroom inside her Tucson, Arizona home, guiding her daughter, Savannah, and her Today show colleagues through her daily bed-making routine. Police are now treating that same bedroom as a crime scene. On Wednesday, March 11, on her The Megyn Kelly Show, Kelly broke down the footage.
“Well, I think everybody needs to know how to make a bed. So, when the time came to teach [Savannah and her siblings] how to make a bed, this is what I tried to teach you,” Nancy explained in the clip, with the hosts laughing at Savannah and following along as Nancy showed how she made her bed every day.
“So what’s interesting about that clip is you can see where [Nancy] slept every night,” Kelly said, per Parade. “And you can see exactly what this abductor must have walked into. I mean, does anybody’s mother dramatically overhaul their bedroom when they’re in their 80s, 70s? I mean, that was, what, 13 years ago?”
Kelly added, “The point is simply you can see right into her bedroom and, generally, the way it was and the way it was set up. And she lives in the same house.”
The footage, Kelly suggested, could have been something the kidnapper studied. “We had an alleged kidnapper note early on in the Nancy Guthrie scandal, claiming they knew exactly where she kept her Apple Watch,” Kelly said. “And they had described something inside Nancy’s bedroom…Did those people behind that note see this segment?”
Law enforcement could never confirm that the ransom notes were authentic because no proof of life was provided. Kelly theorized there was enough in the video to “write a very convincing kidnap note” even if the person sending it wasn’t actually the kidnapper. “I could describe the inside of that room to a T,” Kelly said. “And if you didn’t know that the Today show had aired that footage in 2013, you would be very convinced that I had been inside Nancy Guthrie’s bedroom… I wonder whether the authorities are even aware that this was broadcast publicly.”
According to Kelly, the video could have been crucial in “potentially giving you a road map for what you would encounter once you go into that bedroom, if you were a bad guy willing to do some homework.”
This comes after the latest in the investigation has people speculating that Nancy did not walk out of her home the night of February 1. When police arrived at her house after Guthrie was reported missing, they found blood on the front door, on the porch, and on the driveway. She has not been seen since.
The reward for information about Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance is up to $1 million.
The Mafia Boss Watched His Maid Care for His Mother in Secret—Nine Days Later, the Entire House Learned Why He Had Been Watching
Damian Costa had ordered men killed without losing sleep.
But on the ninth night he watched Tessa Miller spoon-feed his dying mother through a security camera, the most feared man in the city sat perfectly still—and realized something inside him was becoming dangerously human.
People thought they knew how monsters were made.
They imagined gunshots in dark alleys. Betrayals whispered behind closed doors. Fathers teaching sons that mercy was weakness before those sons were old enough to understand what mercy meant.
Sometimes, though, a monster was simply a man sitting alone in a windowless basement, surrounded by a hundred glowing screens, waiting for proof that everyone eventually disappointed him.
Damian had spent most of his thirty-eight years collecting that proof.
His estate sat against the cliffs outside the city, an architectural fortress of glass, steel, limestone, and money. Guards patrolled the perimeter. Cameras watched every hallway. Reinforced doors separated the private residence from the offices where Damian conducted business nobody discussed at dinner.
The house had a wine cellar worth several million dollars.
An indoor pool.
A private medical suite.
A ballroom nobody used.
Damian's favorite room was the bunker beneath all of it.
No windows.
No sunlight.
Just screens.
There, nobody could lie to his face.
For the past week, however, Damian had barely watched the gates.
He watched Room 104.
His mother's bedroom.
Beatrice Costa was seventy-two, but Alzheimer's had stolen years from her face and decades from her mind.
Once, she had been terrifying.
Damian remembered her standing at the head of the dinner table after his father died, dressed in black and telling twelve powerful men exactly what would happen if any of them mistook widowhood for weakness.
Nobody did.
Now some mornings Beatrice didn't recognize her own son.
Other mornings she believed Damian was ten.
On the worst days, she didn't know where she was at all.
Those were the days she screamed.
She threw water glasses.
She struck nurses.
She spat out medication and food.
Damian paid registered nurses nearly two thousand dollars a day to provide round-the-clock care. They were trained, credentialed, discreet, and terrified of both their patient and her son.
He saw the disgust they tried to hide.
He understood it.
He hated them for it anyway.
Then, on Tuesday morning, Tessa Miller entered Monitor Four.
She wasn't supposed to matter.
She was twenty-six, worked housekeeping for twelve dollars an hour, and wore a faded gray uniform with white canvas sneakers that had been scrubbed so many times the fabric was beginning to separate from the soles.
Damian knew her name because Damian knew everyone's name.
Nobody entered Costa property without a background check.
No criminal history.
Two eviction notices.
Terrible credit.
No family connections that concerned him.
Invisible.
That was what Tessa Miller had been.
Until that Tuesday.
The nurse had just fled Beatrice's room wearing applesauce across her expensive scrubs.
Beatrice sat against the pillows, chest heaving.
Tessa appeared in the doorway pushing a housekeeping cart.
Damian leaned closer to the monitor.
"Don't," he murmured.
Tessa entered.
Beatrice made a warning sound.
Tessa stopped.
Damian's hand moved toward the intercom.
One insult.
One impatient gesture.
One moment of disrespect toward his mother, and Tessa Miller would be escorted off the property before lunch.
Instead, she picked up the abandoned bowl.
"They make this stuff taste like cardboard, don't they?"
Damian's fingers stopped.
Beatrice blinked.
Tessa pulled over an ordinary wooden chair.
"If somebody tried feeding me flavorless mush every morning, I'd probably throw it at them too."
A tiny movement appeared at the corner of Beatrice's mouth.
Damian couldn't tell whether it was irritation or amusement.
Tessa stirred the oatmeal.
"But here's our problem. You don't eat, everybody gets dramatic. Then somebody starts talking about IVs, and nobody wants that."
She lifted a spoon.
She didn't shove it toward Beatrice.
She waited.
One minute.
Two.
Three.
Damian forgot his coffee.
Finally, Beatrice leaned forward.
She ate.
Damian stared.
Tessa smiled as though nothing remarkable had happened.
"There we go. Don't tell anybody I won. It'll ruin my reputation."
By Wednesday, Tessa had somehow become part of Beatrice's routine.
By Thursday, Damian noticed the nurses taking their breaks when the maid arrived.
Tessa never complained.
She cleaned first.
Then she sat.
She fed Beatrice.
Brushed her thinning silver hair.
Wiped her mouth without making a show of it.
And talked.
Not about anything important.
The weather.
A bus that had been forty minutes late.
A diner customer who had tried to pay a twenty-dollar bill using coins.
The ridiculous price of eggs.
Beatrice rarely answered.
Tessa talked anyway.
Damian watched for an angle.
Everyone had one.
Maybe she wanted a better job.
Maybe she knew cameras were watching.
Maybe she intended to steal.
Maybe kindness was simply the opening move in some game he hadn't identified yet.
On Thursday evening, he followed her departure through the camera system.
Rain hammered the property.
Tessa stepped outside wearing a thin jacket.
She didn't have an umbrella.
Her sneakers were soaked almost immediately.
She walked toward the employee shuttle stop with the exhausted posture of someone who still had hours left in her day.
Damian watched the empty driveway after she disappeared.
On Friday, he summoned Paul Mercer, his head of security.
Paul entered the bunker carrying a folder.
"Deep background on Miller."
Damian kept watching Monitor Four.
Tessa sat beside Beatrice reading from an old paperback.
Beatrice's eyes were closed.
"She's asleep," Damian said.
Paul looked at the monitor.
"Miller knows."
"Then why is she still reading?"
"You asked me for information, boss. Not philosophy."
Damian finally held out his hand.
Paul gave him the folder.
"Anything?"
"No mob connections. No law enforcement. No gambling. No drugs. No boyfriend with a grudge. She's almost offensively ordinary."
Damian opened it.
Then he saw the hospital records.
"Her sister?"
"Emily Miller. Leukemia."
Damian's gaze slowed.
"Age?"
"Twenty-one when she died."
"When?"
"Eight months ago."
Paul explained the rest.
Three years of treatments.
Experimental therapy insurance refused to cover.
Tessa had drained every savings account she had.
Then borrowed.
Then borrowed again.
Some loans came from legal companies with ugly interest rates.
Others came from men who made Damian's expression turn cold.
She worked five days at the estate and weekend shifts at a diner.
She lived in a studio apartment above a bowling alley.
She was drowning.
Damian closed the folder.
"How much?"
"Total debt?"
"Yes."
"Just under eighty-seven thousand."
Damian looked toward the monitor.
Tessa was adjusting his mother's blanket.
"She has access to jewelry worth twenty times that."
"She hasn't touched anything."
"Desperate people eventually do desperate things."
Paul studied him.
"Want her transferred?"
Damian should have said yes.
Instead, he heard himself answer, "No."
The next day brought the heat.
Even with the estate's climate-control system working overtime, everyone seemed irritable.
Beatrice became terrified shortly after two.
Damian was meeting with three men about problems at the docks when his phone vibrated.
East Wing alert.
He dismissed the meeting immediately.
By the time he reached the bunker, Room 104 looked destroyed.
A glass pitcher had shattered.
A chair was overturned.
Two nurses stood outside the bedroom.
Beatrice screamed from the bed.
Then Tessa ran into frame.
"No."
Damian stood.
Tessa crossed the broken glass.
Beatrice grabbed a brass clock.
"Get out," Damian whispered at the screen.
The clock flew.
It missed Tessa's head by inches and struck the wall.
She stayed.
"Beatrice."
Another scream.
Tessa lowered herself.
Glass cracked beneath her knees.
"Beatrice, look at me."
Damian gripped the desk.
The old woman's frightened eyes found Tessa.
"It's loud in your head today, isn't it?"
Tessa was afraid.
Damian could hear it.
She stayed anyway.
"You're safe. Nobody is coming through that door. Nobody is going to hurt you."
Beatrice's breathing slowed.
Then the woman Damian had seen stare down armed men thirty years earlier collapsed into tears.
Tessa climbed onto the edge of the bed and held her.
Damian enlarged the image.
Something dark appeared against the sheets.
Blood.
Tessa had sliced her palm.
She didn't even look at it.
She rocked Beatrice until she slept.
Then she cleaned the broken glass herself.
In the bathroom, she wrapped cheap paper towels around her palm and secured them with a rubber band.
Damian stared.
Something moved beneath his ribs.
Respect.
He hated how unfamiliar it felt.
By Monday, the cameras weren't enough.
At 2:15 that afternoon, Damian walked into the East Wing himself.
He stopped outside Room 104.
Tessa's voice floated through the partially open door.
"So the mechanic tells me it's the alternator."
Damian listened.
"I ask how much, and he gives me this number like he's selling me a private jet. Seriously, Beatrice, I should watch one of those tutorials and fix it myself."
A pause.
"You think that's a bad idea?"
Tessa laughed.
"Yeah. Me too. I'd probably blow up the neighborhood."
Damian caught his reflection in the hallway mirror.
Dark hair.
Hard eyes.
Permanent scowl.
A man wearing a suit worth more than Tessa earned in years.
What was he doing?
He had been watching this woman for seven days.
Studying her.
Thinking about her.
Wondering why she behaved like goodness didn't require an audience.
Then Beatrice spoke.
The words were faint.
But Damian heard them.
"Damian."
He froze.
His mother rarely said his name anymore.
Tessa's voice softened.
"Your son?"
"My boy."
Damian couldn't move.
Beatrice whispered something else.
"He's alone."
Silence.
Then Tessa said, "Maybe he doesn't have to be."
Damian's jaw tightened.
He pushed open the door.
Tessa turned.
Her face went white.
Beatrice looked toward him.
For one impossible second, her eyes were clear.
"My boy," she whispered.
Damian stood in the doorway while the woman who had forgotten almost everything remembered him.
And the maid beside her was holding Beatrice's hand.
Tessa rose immediately.
"Mr. Costa."
Her injured palm was bandaged badly.
Damian looked at it.
Then at her.
"You and I," he said quietly, "need to talk."
And from the fear that flashed across Tessa Miller's face, Damian realized she thought she was about to be fired.
She had no idea he had been watching her for seven days.
And she had no idea what he had decided to do on the ninth.
