Chapter 11
Thomas’s death had never been an accident.
Margaret Shaw was indicted on fourteen federal and state counts, including conspiracy to commit murder, attempted murder, major fraud against the United States, obstruction of justice, and witness tampering. Her lawyers fought for eleven months. They lost every single motion.
On the day of her sentencing, she wore pearls.
She was sentenced to life without parole.
Meredith Shaw received twenty-two years for aggravated assault and conspiracy. Cole Brandt, who pleaded guilty and testified, received twenty-five. The woman in scrubs who’d come with flowers that night was identified as a Shaw Security employee named Tara Vance. She cooperated, and she went to prison too.
Colonel Wade Hollister was arrested at the Pentagon in his dress uniform. He was convicted of bribery and conspiracy and stripped of his rank. Judge Raymond Tolliver resigned from the bench three days before the state judicial board could remove him, and was later charged for his role in the forged guardianship. Police Chief Dale Corbin was indicted for obstruction. Lionel Pratt was fired by Hawthorne Regional’s board the same week federal subpoenas arrived.
Harold Finch was named interim chief of police.
He called me the day he was sworn in.
“Funny thing,” he said. “First thing I did was reopen eleven cases the old chief closed too fast. Turns out a lot of folks in this county have been waiting a long time for someone to just do their job.”
The Army reopened its investigation into the helicopter crash that killed Staff Sergeant Danny Okafor and three other soldiers. The cause was officially changed from pilot error to catastrophic mechanical failure of a fraudulently certified tail rotor hub. Every SA-7 assembly in service was grounded and replaced within sixty days. Engineers estimated that the recall probably saved more lives than anyone would ever be able to count.
I drove to Georgia to tell Danny’s widow, Grace, in person.
She sat at her kitchen table with their twin daughters coloring in the next room, and she listened to everything without interrupting. When I finished, she was quiet for a long time.
“They told me he made a mistake,” she said finally. “For a year, I’ve been angry at a man who didn’t do anything wrong.”
“He didn’t do anything wrong,” I said. “He did everything right.”
She cried then. And so did I.
Evelyn turned thirty-five in a rehabilitation hospital in Raleigh, with a cast on her leg and a bandage still covering the healing scar on her scalp. Her doctors had certified her fully competent four days earlier. The trust’s lawyers came to her room with the final papers.
Her wrists were still weak. Her hand trembled as she held the pen.
But she signed her own name.
Every letter of it.
Then she set down the pen and looked at me, and she smiled. It was a crooked smile, her face still not fully healed. It was the most beautiful thing I’d ever seen.
As majority owner of Shaw Aeronautics, Evelyn’s first act was to bring in an independent board and a new chief executive with an unblemished safety record. Her second was to open the company’s entire testing archive to federal investigators. Her third was to establish the Catherine Shaw Foundation, funded by her own shares, to support the families of service members killed in aviation accidents.
Its first scholarships went to two little girls in Georgia.
The company was renamed six months later. Evelyn said the Shaw name had carried enough weight for one lifetime.
Faith testified at every trial. She never once looked away from her mother. Afterward, she moved into the small cottage at the edge of our property and went back to school to become a trauma nurse. Rosalind Bell wrote her recommendation letter.
Laurel took over as the new company’s chief compliance officer. She and Evelyn talked on the phone almost every day. Sometimes about work. Mostly not.
The other sisters were harder. Jocelyn, Paige, and Sabrina had known things were wrong in that family and had chosen comfort over courage. None of them had touched Evelyn that night, but none of them had protected her either. Evelyn didn’t pretend that didn’t matter. But one afternoon in the spring, Sabrina showed up at our door with a casserole she’d clearly burned, and stood on the porch crying, saying she was sorry for every year she’d looked the other way.
Evelyn let her in.
May you like
“Forgiveness isn’t the same as forgetting,” she told me later that night. “And it isn’t the same as trust. But it’s a door. I’d rather leave it open a crack than nail it shut and become someone like her.”
Abner Pruitt lived to see all of it. He came to our house every Sunday for supper. He told Evelyn that her pecan pie was the second-best he’d ever had, and refused, every single week, to say who made the first.
