Chapter 4
“And Lily?” I asked. “What did you tell yourself about Lily?”
She had no answer. The police separated all three of them. Evelyn was taken into custody that night. Tyler and Vanessa were transported separately for questioning. The computer, security recorder, electrolyte bottle, custody petition, Rachel’s phone, and both vehicle key fobs were collected as evidence.
I returned to the hospital just before midnight. Lily was sleeping beneath a lightweight blanket, monitored by a nurse who checked her temperature every few minutes. The doctors believed she would recover without permanent injury, but they wanted to observe her overnight.
Rachel was awake. Her voice was weak, and she looked smaller than she had that morning. When I entered, she reached for my hand.
“Lily?”
“She’s safe.”
Rachel closed her eyes, and tears slipped into her hair. I did not tell her to be strong. I did not tell her everything would be fine. I had spent too many years as a school administrator watching frightened children forced to comfort adults with optimistic lies. I simply held her hand and told her what was true.
“You are not alone.”
May you like
She remembered more than Tyler expected. That afternoon, Tyler had told her he wanted to discuss their marriage at my house because it was “neutral ground.” He brought Vanessa with him, claiming honesty required everyone to be present. Rachel had refused to leave Lily with Evelyn, so she brought the baby along.
Inside Tyler’s SUV, Evelyn handed Rachel an electrolyte drink and said she looked dehydrated. Rachel took several sips. Within twenty minutes, she felt dizzy. When they arrived at my house and discovered I was gone, Evelyn produced the custody petition. She told Rachel to sign a statement admitting she had experienced dangerous thoughts after giving birth. In exchange, Evelyn promised the document would remain private and Tyler would continue paying household expenses during the divorce.
