Chapter 4 - The Red Coat
Vanessa stood at the top of the stairs, breathing heavily. The chandelier cast harsh shadows across her smeared lipstick, making her look unhinged.
"She was leaving you!" Vanessa screamed again, waving the leather-bound journal. "Caroline hated this life! She hated the mafia, she hated the violence, and she was taking Sophie to Philadelphia to hide her from you forever!"
Luca slowly walked toward her. "Where did you get that book, Vanessa?"
"I found it in her locked vanity!" she spat, tears streaming down her face. "I was trying to protect you, Luca. I knew if you read her diary, it would break your heart. She bought that train ticket. She packed her bags. She was running away from you the day her car crashed!"
Luca stopped. The betrayal in his eyes was almost too painful to look at. For three years, he had worshipped his late wife's memory. To hear that she was abandoning him—stealing his daughter away—was a fatal blow.
He reached out and took the journal.
I stood in the doorway of Sophie’s room, my heart hammering. Something was wrong. The pieces didn't fit. If Caroline was running away to Philadelphia, why did Laura Bennett—the Philadelphia dance director—tell Luca earlier tonight that Vanessa had paid her to evaluate Sophie?
"Mr. Moretti," I said softly.
Luca didn't hear me. He opened the journal. The pages were filled with elegant cursive writing. He stared at a dated entry.
October 12th. I can't take this life anymore. Luca's world is too dangerous. I bought the ticket. I'm taking Sophie to Pennsylvania. He will never find us.
Luca’s shoulders slumped. The heavy, invincible mafia boss suddenly looked like a broken man. "She... she hated me."
Vanessa immediately softened her voice, stepping closer and placing a hand on his chest. "Oh, Luca. I didn't want you to know. She was a coward. But I’m here. I’m not running. I will stay by your side and be the mother Sophie actually needs."
Luca closed his eyes, gripping the journal tightly.
I couldn't stay quiet. I stepped out of the bedroom. "Mr. Moretti, may I see the journal?"
Vanessa whipped her head toward me, her eyes flashing with pure venom. "Excuse me? You are a maid. Go back to the kitchen before I have you thrown into the street!"
"Claire," Luca said wearily. "Not now."
"Please, sir. Just for one second."
Luca looked at me. He had always treated me with quiet respect. Slowly, he handed me the leather book.
I looked at the cursive handwriting. The loops on the 'y's and the sharp angles on the 't's.
My mother had been a bank teller for thirty years before her fall. She taught me how to spot check fraud when I was a teenager. I knew handwriting.
I looked up at Vanessa. "When did you find this?"
"Two months ago," Vanessa snapped. "Not that it's any of your business."
"And you said Caroline wrote this the week before she died?"
"Yes! Can't you read?"
I turned the journal over and looked at the back cover. Then I looked at Luca.
"Sir," I said quietly, my hands shaking. "Caroline died three years ago. In 2023."
"Yes," Luca said.
I flipped the book open to the very last page, pointing to a small, embossed manufacturer's stamp at the bottom corner of the paper.
"This journal was printed by the Moleskine company," I said, my voice echoing in the quiet hall. "And the copyright date stamped right here... is 2025."
The silence that fell over the staircase was suffocating.
Vanessa stopped breathing.
Luca slowly lowered his head to look at the tiny print I was pointing at.
© 2025.
"A woman who died in 2023," I said, staring directly into Vanessa’s terrified eyes, "could not have written in a notebook manufactured two years after her death."
Luca’s head snapped up. The grief in his eyes instantly vanished, replaced by a terrifying, lethal rage.
"You forged it," Luca whispered.
Vanessa stumbled backward, her heel catching on the carpet. "No! No, I swear—"
"You forged my dead wife's handwriting to make me think she was leaving me." Luca advanced on her, his voice dropping to a demonic whisper. "You planted the ticket in the bag. You made up the story about Philadelphia."
"Luca, please!" Vanessa sobbed, backing up against the railing.
"Why, Vanessa? Why are you trying to erase Caroline?"
Before Vanessa could answer, the heavy oak doors at the bottom of the grand staircase violently burst open.
A dozen men in dark suits poured into the foyer. And walking behind them was an older man with silver hair and a heavy cane. Don Bellini. Vanessa’s father.
"What the hell is going on here?" the Don roared, looking up at the balcony. "My daughter calls me crying, saying the engagement is off because of a maid?"
Vanessa immediately shrieked, "Papa! Help me! He's going to kill me!"
Don Bellini’s men drew their weapons. Luca’s guards instantly rushed into the foyer, pulling their own guns. Within seconds, a full-blown mafia standoff erupted in the entryway of the mansion.
"Put the guns down, Bellini," Luca warned, his voice echoing over the chaos. "Your daughter is sick."
"She’s your fiancée!" Bellini shouted. "You disrespect her, you disrespect me. And you know what that means for the treaty, Moretti!"
I backed away from the balcony, terrified by the drawn weapons. I slipped back toward Sophie's room. But as I passed the hall closet, I noticed the door was slightly ajar.
Vanessa’s red winter coat was hanging inside.
Earlier this afternoon, Sophie had been drawing with her crayons in the kitchen. She had been drawing a picture of the day her mother died. She said it made her feel better to draw it.
I saw a piece of paper sticking out of Vanessa’s coat pocket.
I pulled it out.
May you like
It was Sophie’s crayon drawing. It showed Caroline’s black car, the broken tire, and the rainy street. But standing next to the car’s front wheel wasn't a mechanic.
It was a woman. Wearing a bright red coat. Holding a pair of silver wire cutters.
