Chapter 2 - THE HOUSE ON WEST ADDISON
Vanessa reached across the white linen tablecloth and grabbed the cardboard box before Sal could pick it up.
Her manicure left crescent marks on the brown edges.
“If you walk out that door, Luca, this marriage is over,” she said, her voice cracking in front of thirty of Chicago’s most powerful people.
Luca didn’t even blink.
He reached down, pried her fingers off the cardboard one by one, and picked up the tiny red mitten himself.
“The marriage paused the second you lied to me,” Luca said quietly. “Whether it survives the night depends on what I find on West Addison.”
From the far end of the table, Vanessa’s father, Arthur Bellini, stood up slowly.
His silver hair gleamed under the crystal chandelier, his expression stiff with the kind of political calculation that had kept his construction empire afloat for forty years.
“Vanessa,” Arthur said, his voice booming with warning. “Sit down. Let Luca clear his head.”
I watched Vanessa look at her father.
She wasn’t looking at him for comfort.
She was looking at him with pure terror—as if Arthur Bellini was the last person in the room who should hear what waited on West Addison.
Luca noticed it too.
He turned to me before I could slip back toward the kitchen door.
“Emma.”
I froze, my hands clasped in front of my black housekeeper’s uniform. “Yes, sir?”
“Get your coat.”
A murmur rippled through the dining room.
“Me, sir?” I asked.
“If there is a six-year-old boy in that house, he doesn’t need two grown men in dark suits walking into his living room after nine o’clock at night without a woman present,” Luca said.
Then his cold gray eyes shifted back to his fiancée.
“And since you have been honest with me tonight, Emma, I’d like you in the car. Coming, Vanessa?”
Vanessa swallowed hard, lifted her chin, and walked out of the dining room without her purse, her red silk train whispering across the hardwood floor like a lit fuse.
Five minutes later, the four of us were inside Luca’s black Mercedes sedan.
Sal sat behind the wheel, his shoulders square inside the dark driving coat Vanessa had tried to banish thirty minutes earlier.
I sat in the front passenger seat because Luca insisted on sitting in the back with Vanessa, where he could watch her face under the passing streetlights.
For the first ten minutes, nobody spoke.
The rain had started again, streaking the tinted windows as we left the manicured mansions of the Gold Coast behind and drove west toward working-class brick bungalows and quiet neighborhood parishes.
I looked down at the center console, where Sal had set his cardboard box between us.
The sealed birthday card with LUCA written across the front had slid out from beneath the framed 1992 photograph.
Without thinking, my fingers brushed the corner of the envelope.
It felt thick—too heavy for just paper.
Sal caught my eye in the rearview mirror and gave his head the slightest shake.
Not yet, his eyes said.
In the back seat, Luca turned the small red wool mitten over in his hands.
“Did you knit this?” he asked Vanessa.
“No,” she whispered, staring out the window.
“Did you buy it?”
“No.”
“Have you been paying rent on this house?”
Vanessa pressed her forehead against the cold glass. “Every Tuesday for four years.”
My breath caught.
Four years.
Luca and Vanessa had only been engaged for eight months, arranged carefully between the Moretti and Bellini families after three decades of bitter rivalry.
“Who is his father, Vanessa?” Luca asked, his voice dangerously steady.
“If I tell you, you’ll turn this car around and ruin three lives,” she said. “And none of them are mine.”
“Try me.”
Before she could answer, Sal eased the sedan to the curb beneath a flickering streetlamp.
“This is it,” Sal said softly.
It wasn’t the glamorous hideaway of a wealthy woman’s secret affair.
It was a narrow, single-story yellow brick bungalow with a chain-link fence, a rusted tricycle on the concrete stoop, and a plastic pumpkin sitting beside the front door.
Warm yellow light glowed behind crooked mini-blinds.
Vanessa grabbed Luca’s wrist with both hands.
Her diamond engagement ring caught the amber streetlight.
“Luca, swear to me you won’t lose your temper inside this house,” she begged, and for the first time all night, the arrogant socialite was completely gone. “Swear to me on your mother’s soul.”
Luca looked down at her trembling hands.
That was when everything I thought I knew about Vanessa Bellini shifted.
She wasn’t hiding guilt.
She was guarding someone.
Luca opened his door without making the promise.
We followed him up the cracked front walk—Vanessa practically running in her heels to reach the porch ahead of him, Sal right behind me with the red mitten in his coat pocket.
Before Vanessa could knock, the front door opened a crack against a brass security chain.
An older woman with tired eyes and a faded floral cardigan peered out.
“Vanessa?” the woman whispered in a thick Italian accent. “You already came Tuesday. What’s wrong?”
Then the woman saw Luca standing behind her on the porch steps.
She didn’t gasp.
She crossed herself.
“Madonna mia,” the woman breathed, backing away from the door as she fumbled with the chain. “He looks just like him.”
Luca stepped into the small, overheated living room, which smelled of tomato sauce, crayons, and baby powder.
Before he could ask the woman what she meant, small footsteps pattered down the narrow hallway.
A little boy in faded blue pajamas stopped dead at the edge of the rug.
He had dark curly hair, solemn brown eyes, and a gap where his front tooth should have been.
He looked past Luca and smiled brightly at Vanessa.
“Mommy Vee!” the boy said, holding up a crumpled piece of yellow construction paper. “I drawed the big boat!”
Mommy Vee.
Not Mom.
Luca went rigid beside me.
“Vanessa,” Luca said, his voice dropping an octave. “Why does he call you Mommy Vee?”
The boy’s dark eyes shifted toward Luca, curious and completely unafraid.
And as the hallway light fell across the child’s face, I heard Sal draw in a sharp, ragged breath behind me.
Because above the boy’s left eyebrow was a tiny, crescent-shaped birthmark—the exact same mark Luca’s younger brother, Matteo, had carried in every portrait hanging in the Moretti mansion before he died in a car crash five years ago.
May you like
The little boy pointed a small finger straight at Sal’s dark coat.
“Look, Nonna,” the boy said happily. “The man from my picture came back!”
